Cynthia Hancox.com
  • Home
    • About >
      • Cynthia's Sites
      • Personal Testimonies
  • Homeschooling
    • Application Reviews
    • Application Writing
    • Phone Consultations
    • Support & Advocacy
    • Government Liaison
    • Feedback
  • Contact
  • Information Index
    • Information
    • Videos
  • Products
    • Exemption Guide
    • Planning Your Programme
    • Topic Plans & Unit Studies
    • Basic Exemption Guide
    • Book of Centuries
  • Donate

Government Review of "Home-based Educators"?

2/20/2018

3 Comments

 
In July 2017, then-Opposition spokeman for education, Chris Hipkins, announced a number of proposed changes or review of the education system which Labour would act upon if elected. The mention of "home-based educators" included there sent ripples of concern through the home education community. Today our Labour-led government, via Mr Hipkins, now Minister for Education, formally announced the beginning of those proposed reviews. Again, families are concerned about what this might mean for home educators. Let's take a closer look:

Home-based Early Childhood Education

The last several governments have been keen on promoting the value of "early childhood education" especially via Early Childhood Education centres, and Labour is no different. All children ages 3, 4 & 5 in NZ are entitled to up to 20 hours a week of ECE funding, paid for by the government. That funding is the primary way in which the government funds ECE in NZ. 

As an alternative to ECE in facilities such as a kindergarten, some parents prefer home-based ECE services, where their children are cared for and educated in a family home with a small number of other young children (5 or less), allowing for more personal attention and a more family-like atmosphere. Providers of such services can still be paid the ECE 20 hour per child funding, so long as they meet the government's criteria to have a licensed home-based ECE service.

Because the government is paying for these services, they have the right to set out certain criteria. 

What Mr Hipkins and the Labour government have proposed is to review home-based early childhood education services, and investigate the introduction of minimum qualifications levels for these educators. 

In the wording of all documents, announcements etc, it has been clear that they are referring to the providers of home-based ECE services, rather than to home educators in general (ie homeschoolers). Where the term "home-based educators" is used, it is within the context of a heading or section specifically stating it is about "the review of home-based early childhood education," such as on page 21 of this Cabinet document on the reviews being sought. 

Wider Review

​This review is also not targeted only at home-based ECE providers; ECEs in general will be reviewed, and incentives given to thos who employ only fully qualified teachers. There are also a number of other parts to the review, such as reviewing NCEA, the Tomorrow's Schools policies that have underpinned the education system since 1989 and so forth. 

In so far as I have seen, there has been nothing whatsoever that indicates an intention to review home education policies. Home education/homeschooling is certainly not mentioned at all in the Cabinet proposal or any documents so far released. 

Will This Labour-NZ First Government Bring Changes to Home Education?

The short answer is we don't know. During the lead up to the elections, Chris Hipkins submitted thousands of written questions to the then-Minister of Education Hekia Parata on a range of matters. Within those many, many questions were only 7 connected to home education. They were (summarised):
  • What criteria does the MoE use to assess home education applications?
  • How many home education applications have been approved in the last 5 years?
  • How many applications have been declined in the last 5 years?
  • Why were they declined?
  • How many home educated students have been directed to attend a registered school because they were not meeting the required standards in the last 5 years?
  • What checks, if any, does the MoE make on the quality of education being provided for home educated students?
  • What checks, if any, does the MoE make on the physical environment and safety of home educated students?
All of these questions were answered (some not very accurately). What Mr Hipkins or his party made of the answers or intend to do with them, if anything, remains unknown. 

What we do know, though, is that so far our current government have not released any statements or information that indicate an intention to review home education. I believe that they have so many other aspects of education to focus on at present that they are unlikely to do so in the near future. Keep in mind that at around 0.7% of the total student population, home educators are, to the government's mind, small in number and therefore not all that important. 

A new government which is seeking to consolidate it's position in its first term is unlikely to focus much time or resources on relatively insignificant matters. 

Previously, less than favourable changes for home educators have been instigated by NZ First while in co-power, and of course we once again have NZ First in government together with Labour. However, the current Associate Minister for Education, Tracey Martin (NZ First), herself a former home educator, responded (as Deputy Leader and Education Spokesperson for NZ First) to the Home Education Foundation's request to each party for their position on home education in 2014 by saying: 
"At this time the New Zealand First Manifesto is silent in the area of Home Schooling. The reason for this is that no member of the Home Schooling community approached us over the last three years to inform us of any difficulties or areas of concern/improvement. New Zealand First does not create policy without first having a relationship with those to be directly affected by that policy.
Having Home Schooled one of our sons for a period of time I have a working understanding of the current environment under which the parents and students you represent are working."
NZ First was also shown in the Family First's brochure on election issues to support parental choice for education.
​
Nothing in their 2017 manifesto suggested any change.

As a sidenote of possible interest, Tracey Martin has written all the education policy for NZ First since 2008. She is currently one of three Associate Ministers of Education, so has certain areas of responsbility, one of the chief being Learning Support (Special Ed). THIS is a very interesting interview with her. 

So Do We Just Relax?

On the one hand, there is nothing to be concerned about in regards to the intended review of home-based ECE educators, as that has nothing to do with home education. 

HOWEVER, we do need to remain alert, informed, wise and responsive. Any government can make decisions that DO affect home educators. If we do not keep ourselves informed, and respond appropriately, we may miss the opportunity to take action to protect our rights and freedoms as home educating parents. 

I recommend the following:
  • READ the Cabinet paper on the current review so you know what the proposals and intentions are, HERE
  • Be CONNECTED to other home educators in ways which increase the likelihood of you being informed of issues that arise. For example, joining NCHENZ (free) means you will receive a quarterly newsletter. You can also join their Facebook page. There are numerous NZ home ed Facebook groups - some general, and some special interest. And then there are regional support groups and networks. 
  • CHECK FACTS via a reliable source before reacting to an "issue" though - sometimes well meaning people misunderstand something and lots of speculation and worry can be rife unnecessarily.
  • REMAIN AWARE of announcements, news articles and so forth related to education, and if you see something that could affect home education, then check the facts and discuss with experienced home educators. Let NCHENZ know if there is something of concern that needs to be investigated or addressed.
  • SUPPORT the people who are proactively working to promote the interests of home educators. The NCHENZ committee, including myself, and Todd Roughton of Homeschooling NZ are some of the key ones who come to mind, along with those people within some regional groups who are liasing with the regional MoE offices. (More regional liaisons are needed - talk to me if you're interested!)
  • PLAY YOUR PART by being aware of your rights and responsibilities as a home educator, and acting in a way that reflects well on the whole home education community. (More on this in a future post)
  • STEP UP when called upon - if NCHENZ or another reliable home education source inform you of issues that need to be addressed and actions to take, please do your part. 
Enjoy the freedom you have to home educate your children. But never take it for granted! Remember, a lot of the freedom you now have is there because those who went before you did these things, without the benefit of the internet. 
Picture
3 Comments

    Information Blog

    This page is where I will share information on various topics relevant to home education. The Information Index page lists all topics by group, or use the Categories below.

    New to homeschooling?

    Start HERE

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    September 2019
    November 2018
    August 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    July 2016
    May 2016

    Categories

    All
    2023 MoE Review
    5 Year Olds
    ACE
    Advocacy
    Census
    Christmas Period
    COVID 19
    Declarations
    Declined Exemptions
    Disabled Students
    Distance Learning
    Early Childhood
    Early Leaving Exemptions
    Education And Training Bill
    Education & Training Act
    Employment Of Students
    ERO
    Exemptions
    Family Numbers
    Foreign Students And Visitors
    Getting Started
    Governmental Review
    High School Qualifications
    Importing Resources
    In The News
    Irlens
    Jury Duty
    Lapbooks
    Learning Difficulties
    Legal Information
    Media Interviews
    Media Requests
    Ministry Contacts
    Ministry Processes
    More Info Requests
    Multi-Child Applications
    NCEA
    NSNs
    Part Time Homeschooling
    Playcentre
    Private School Operating As
    Schonell & Burt Tests
    School Trials
    Socialisation
    Statistics
    Success Stories
    Supervision Allowance
    Surveys
    Te Kura
    Truancy/Attendance
    Unexpectedly Homeschooling
    Videos

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.